Places To Eat In Plattsburgh Ny: The 14 Best Restaurants to Try

1. Overview of places to eat in Plattsburgh NY

If you're looking for the best places to eat in Plattsburgh NY, you're in for a treat. This charming city offers a diverse array of restaurants in Plattsburgh, NY that cater to every taste and budget.

From classic Italian fare at Arnie's Restaurant to authentic Caribbean flavors at Island Vybz, these top Plattsburgh restaurants showcase the city's vibrant culinary scene. Whether you're a local looking for a new favorite spot or a visitor seeking a memorable dining experience, get ready to embark on a delicious journey through the best places to eat in Plattsburgh NY.

2. Arnie's Restaurant

Arnie's Restaurant is a beloved place to eat in Plattsburgh Ny. An old-school Italian restaurant on Margaret St since 1951.

Lures red-sauce fans with neon beacon. A no-frills eatery serving Italian staples. Family atmosphere for hearty Italian meals, vegetarian dishes, kids' menu, great cocktails.

Raves about excellent service, incredible food. Homemade bread, roasted turkey, fresh-cut fries. Lobster ravioli, sausage ravioli with standout rose sauce are delicious.

Fast, efficient servers deliver truly delightful traditional dinner despite being busy.

Quirky 1970's upstairs dining room charms. Homemade ravioli with sausage, broccolini, peppers is outstanding. Portions huge like enormous bacon burger.

Most praise excellent waitstaff. But one knocked rude server despite no ‘wait' sign. Food fantastic but ruined night.

For many, Arnie's sparks sentimental memories of great pizza from childhood. A long-standing Plattsburgh favorite restaurant for classic Italian like shrimp scampi, spaghetti meat sauce. Mozzarella pizza, chicken alfredo, fried calamari earn top marks.

Convenient parking. Easily accessible gem with incredible homemade cuisine in charming, outdated setting. Beware potentially cold service, drink waits. But bacon wrapped shrimp amazing.

ARNIE'S RESTAURANT

Address: 20 Margaret St, Plattsburgh, NY 12901, United States

Hours: 11 AM – 9 PM

Phone: +1 518-563-3003

Menu: arniesoriginal.com

3. Sip

Sip is a locally owned, relaxed hangout – one of the top places to eat in Plattsburgh Ny. Started by buddies who played pop punk.

Simple model: Fresh food, adult beverages, friendly service, fun atmosphere, creative culinary surprises. Major draw – elevated pub eats, craft cocktails, draft beer.

A hidden gem restaurant with outdoor seating, great cocktails, vegan dishes. Patrons love the delicious food, chill vibe. Faves include crispy calamari, chicken sandwiches, spicy tacos. Surprise – punk rock playlist.

Despite busy times, excellent service wows. Raves about amazing food and vibe. Paid lot, street parking.

Fan favorites: Tedford special, fried shrimp/mussels, meaty wings, refreshing cocktails. Even picky eaters love the juicy, flavorful burgers. Praise for kitchen crew.

One group got unacceptable cold service. But rare at this wonderful restaurant known for fresh, made-to-order fare.

Sip scores with trendy decor, fun murals, meals elevated by quality ingredients. Vegan options like tofu sammies, falafel wraps. Incredible waitstaff but suggest vegan kids' items.

A must-visit Plattsburgh dining spot with great food, cocktails, service, funky vibe – the perfect hangout.

SIP

Address: 14 Margaret St, Plattsburgh, NY 12901, United States

Hours: 11:30 AM – 9 PM

Phone: +1 518-566-4500

4. Island Vybz

Hidden on Clinton St is Island Vybz – a Caribbean/Jamaican gem among places to eat in Plattsburgh Ny. Offers hard-to-find products, traditional food.

A humble takeout spot serving authentic, excellent island fare. Good prices. Old, funky vibe but genuine hospitality shines.

Rave reviews for generous portions, absolutely delicious dishes – oxtail, curry chicken, rice and peas.

One visitor blown away – “Best oxtail ever!” Regulars love the to-die-for jerk chicken, “fantastic home feeling.”

Limited seating but pleasant staff, great service. Compact menu covers classic Jamaican staples. Few vegetarian options but amazing fried chicken for meat-lovers.

Nearly full street parking challenge but spaces open up. Must-trys – chicken curry, brown stew chicken, beef patties with coco bread.

Skip fast food for this authentic Caribbean dining experience at Island Vybz. Incredible flavors make regulars of many. As one fan says – “Don't miss it!”

Island Vybz is a Jamaican restaurant gem among places to eat in Plattsburgh Ny.

ISLAND VYBZ

Address: 26 Clinton St, Plattsburgh, NY 12901, United States

Hours: 12 PM – 9 PM

Phone: +1 518-310-1273

5. YAMA Sushi

Yama Sushi is a local dining destination and Japanese restaurant among places to eat in Plattsburgh Ny. Wins fans with delectable sushi, authentic cuisine.

A family-friendly spot with orange walls. Prides itself on quality, freshness. Earns stellar reputation for diverse menu, friendly atmosphere.

Many rave about generous portions, tasty fare like sushi platters, rolls. “Excellent cuisine, reasonable prices, outstanding service.” A new family favorite for vegetarian, non-veggie options.

Plant-based choices get kudos. Tofu protein satisfies vegans. Highlights – Crazy Roll, Volcano Roll, Tempura Roll, bento boxes, soups. Sushi lovers praise fresh fish, delicious eel and avocado.

Not fancy, but great food, great prices. Friendly servers, attentive care. Even boisterous family didn't disrupt regulars. Some note recent service lapses, new staff seemed bothered.

Fans recommend Tempura Udon though ingredients tricky locally. Hopes for kakiage udon/soba. But YAMA remains a beloved Japanese restaurant, fresh quality sushi keeps locals coming.

For affordable family feast of delicious rolls, sashimi in casual setting, YAMA is local dining gem. An excellent Japanese food experience downtown.

YAMA Sushi

Address: 62 Margaret St, Plattsburgh, NY 12901, United States

Hours: 11 AM – 9 PM

Phone: +1 518-566-8885

Menu: yamasushiny.com

6. Friendly bites

Friendly Bites is latest tantalizing addition to downtown – a Latino spot among places to eat in Plattsburgh Ny. Serves fresh, savory fare transporting fans to NYC flavors.

Diners rave about standouts – lomo saltado, empanadas, chicken tacos, pollo la plancha, seasoned pork steak. Shrimp tacos kid-please. Bright guacamole wows with freshness. Veggie lovers praise tasty, high-quality produce.

Limited seating but friendly hosts are welcoming. Owners cook and serve – feel like “favorite auntie's house”. Cute chalkboard occupies kids.

Quick service, great portions for quick bite or full meal. Many get delivery for flavorful, home-cooked Latin fare. Hot empanadas, juicy proteins travel well.

Diners appreciate amazing service, aromatic smells, fluffy rice, sizzling proteins, fresh-squeezed juices. Faves – strawberry horchata, pineapple juice. Even chicharrones, pickled onions earn praise.

Affordable prices, large portions make Friendly Bites a bargain. Quickly a local gem with raves for phenomenal, flavor-packed Latin cuisine.

Visit this family-owned, casual eatery downtown. With friendly service, quick bites, delicious homestyle, Friendly Bites transports you to vibrant Latin tastes and warmth.

Friendly Bites is a rising Latino restaurant gem among places to eat in Plattsburgh Ny.

FRIENDLY BITES

Address: 37 Bridge St, Plattsburgh, NY 12901, United States

Hours: 10 AM–6:30 PM

Phone: +1 518-310-1504

7. Zuke's Corner Store

In Plattsburgh's heart sits Zuke's Corner Store – a longtime neighborhood market and deli among top places to eat in Plattsburgh Ny. Serving traditional subs, sandwiches, soups, salads, breakfast for 20+ years.

A must-try? The wildly popular Zuke's Special sandwich. Fans rave about fresh, quality ingredients like homemade bread. Perfectly balanced flavors, not overly salty. Even first-timers blown away by generous portions, delicious fare.

Unassuming market setting, no plush seating. But excellent service, friendly staff make up for it. Regulars appreciate consistent smiles, attentiveness even during rushes. “A business that cares about customers.”

For dietary restrictions, new gluten-free rolls game-changer. Standouts include fresh meats, soft hoagie rolls, tempting homemade cookies.

Primarily takeout spot but wins over travelers too with convenience for quick dine-in or grab-and-go subs. Limited parking but quality worth short waits.

After 20 years, Zuke's reigns as top sub/sandwich shop per locals. With excellent customer service, high-quality fare, reasonable prices, friendly neighborhood vibe, this humble corner store is beloved Plattsburgh dining gem.

Zuke's Corner Store is an iconic neighborhood deli among places to eat in Plattsburgh Ny.

ZUKE'S CORNER STORE

Address: 113 Brinkerhoff St, Plattsburgh, NY 12901, United States

Hours: 8 AM–7 PM

Phone: +1 518-563-5544

Menu: zukesdeli.com

8. Quiche et Crepe

Hidden among places to eat in Plattsburgh NY is Quiche et Crepe – a cozy French eatery. This quaint cafe transports you to France.

Diners rave about peaceful patio, water feature, tranquil ambiance. Attentive service from gracious owners. Many call it best gluten-free dining among Plattsburgh restaurants.

The authentic French fare shines – mouthwatering Quiche Lorraine, moist gluten-free crepes. Breakfast highlights savory Crepe Benedict, flaky croissants. Almond croissant a sweet must-try.

For lunch/dinner, broccoli mushroom quiche favorite, beautifully presented with tomato soup. Recommend farm-fresh local egg dishes.

Small menu covers satisfying French staples with passion by multilingual staff. Montrealers order in mother tongue.

Reasonable prices, quick service make it ideal casual stop for road-trippers. Lovely outdoor seating welcomes pup companions.

Interior may seem dated but adds old-world charm. Heavenly pastries in dessert case tempt all.

Grab a table inside or on delightful terrace for delicious French home cooking at this hidden gem making you feel welcomed like family among places to eat in Plattsburgh NY.

Quiche et Crepe is a charming French restaurant gem among places to eat in Plattsburgh NY.

QUICHE ET CREPE

Address: 164 Boynton Ave Suite 204, Plattsburgh, NY 12901, United States

Hours: 8:30 AM – 5 PM

Phone: +1 518-561-4086

9. Texas Roadhouse

For lively dining among places to eat in Plattsburgh NY, Texas Roadhouse delivers. A chain steakhouse with Legendary Food, Legendary Fun.

Serves up hearty American fare, Southwestern spin, Texas-themed decor. Boasts hand-cut steaks, fall-off-the-bone ribs, made-from-scratch sides, fresh-baked bread. Larger portions, handcrafted dishes. Ice-cold beers, legendary margaritas.

But food isn't the only legend. Line dancers, jukebox, friendly servers provide nonstop fun, lively atmosphere. Top reviews for servers' impeccable service, professionalism.

Signatures – pork chops, steak tips, herb chicken, juicy burgers. Addictive cinnamon butter, onion blossom. Even first-timers rave delicious portions.

Classics shine – tender ribs, premium hand-cut steaks cooked perfectly. Fresh salads contrast. Vegetarian options among Southwestern-inspired fare.

No reservations mean waits. But diners find it well worth it for high quality, hearty meals, lively Texas-sized fun atmosphere. Just don't overdo addictive cinnamon buns!

For exceptional dining experience, bold flavors, legendary service, visit Texas Roadhouse – standout among places to eat and restaurants in Plattsburgh, NY.

TEXAS ROADHOUSE

Address: 356 Cornelia St, Plattsburgh, NY 12901, United States

Hours: 3 PM – 10 PM

Phone: +1 518-566-7427

10. Mickey's Restaurant & Lounge

Established 1955, Mickey's Restaurant & Lounge is a true landmark among places to eat in Plattsburgh NY. An easygoing, veteran Italian restaurant with wraparound bar. A gathering spot for friends and family.

In historic lake city, Mickey's beckons with cold beverages, satisfying American fare, traditional setting. Cozy interior, fireplace for watching sports over drinks and meals.

Diners rave ample portions – eggplant parm, pasta favorites, fruits of the sea. Fried duck wontons a flavor explosion. Rotating weekend desserts like cinnamon apple cheesecake are must-tries.

Attentive service elevates special occasions. Goes above and beyond for anniversaries, accommodates vegetarians, kids' menu. Even takeout perfectly cooked pizzas satisfy – pepperoni, mushroom, sausage.

Some dishes bit overcooked. But most praise delicious, hearty fare that feels like home. Chicken parm, beef stroganoff, reuben sandwiches. Seasonal drink specials.

Convenient parking lot, wheelchair access, nice price point. An enjoyable night out with friendly NYC vibes. Locals say the best restaurant in Plattsburgh.

Grab a fireplace table for satisfying, homestyle meal of delicious American-Italian classics at this 65-year institution among beloved places to eat and restaurants in Plattsburgh, NY.

MICKEY'S RESTAURANT & LOUNGE

Address: 26 Riley Ave, Plattsburgh, NY 12901, United States

Hours: 11 AM – 8 PM

Phone: +1 518-561-0066

11. Twisted Carrot

Downtown on Margaret St hides Twisted Carrot – a cozy spot among top places to eat in Plattsburgh NY. Dishes up fresh, innovative fare from local, regional producers.

But real draws? Craft beer, creative cocktails with craft liquors/ingredients. Beer lovers sip rotating drafts, cans, bottles. Cocktail fans delight in seasonal mixes. Mocktails covered too.

Intimate ambiance enhanced by friendly service that makes you feel welcomed. Outdoor seating expands space in warm months.

Meals start strong with deviled eggs. Entree hits – scallops, mussels, risotto, Philly cheesesteak, raved burgers. Meat-free eat fries, veggie burger, salads – many vegan options.

Sweet finale? Comforting yet creative housemade desserts deliver sweet tooth satisfaction.

Diners laud delicious fare showcasing talented chef fusing local, global flavors. Quality ingredients shine in each flawlessly balanced dish.

With reasonable prices, free 2-hour parking, no surprise Twisted Carrot ranks must-visit. Local or just passing through.

One fan raves “outstanding service”, “absolutely amazing food and drinks” for ultimate cozy dining among places to eat and restaurants in Plattsburgh, NY.

TWISTED CARROT

Address: 82 Margaret St, Plattsburgh, NY 12901, United States

Hours: 11 AM – 8 PM

Phone: +1 518-566-4151

Menu: twistedcarrotny.com

12. Nonnalisas

Hidden among places to eat in Plattsburgh NY is Nonnalisa's Italian American Kitchen. An unassuming gem, family-owned labor of love.

Dishes up classic homemade Italian fare. Hand-grated cheeses, fresh-ground meats. Authentic specialties like eggplant parm, baked ziti, lasagna, chicken marsala, seafood alfredo transport you to Italy.

Regulars rave delicious chicken marsala, generously-stuffed manicotti at this Plattsburgh restaurant. Fresh veggies, housemade dressings. Standout low-acid tomato sauce complements like outstanding lasagna – fresh noodles, balanced cheeses.

Even classics eggplant parm, chicken parm earn praise for delightful flavors, ample portions. Seared pork chop highlights exceptional homemade sauces. Lighter? Tasty broccoli chicken alfredo.

Cozy space, limited seating. Takeout for mom's homemade recipes at home. Save room for decadent homespun desserts – fresh berry cheesecake, cannoli cake.

Friendly family staff provides stellar service at this no-frills cash-only gem. Italian music, centerpiece decor add authentic atmosphere.

Nonnalisa's delights with exceptional homestyle Italian-American cooking letting quality ingredients shine. Whether visiting or local.

One diner raves “best lasagna in decades”, “unmissable outstanding authentic flavors” among places to eat in Plattsburgh NY.

Nonnalisa's is a homemade Italian restaurant gem among places to eat in Plattsburgh NY.

NONNALISAS

Address: 20 Plattsburgh Plaza, Plattsburgh, NY 12901, United States

Hours: 2 PM – 8 PM

Phone: +1 518-310-0694

13. Michigans Plus

Michigan's Plus has been a beloved family-owned restaurant among places to eat in Plattsburgh NY for over 40 years. Serves up homemade breakfast, lunch and famous Michigan hot dogs.

This casual diner-style spot delights with delicious all-day breakfasts – hearty omelets, pancakes, benedicts. Lunch brings savory comfort fare and signature Michigan dogs smothered in meaty sauce.

Fans rave about excellent service from amazingly friendly staff making you feel at home. Quick service, fresh, consistently good food at reasonable prices keep regulars coming.

Generous portions win over families with kid's pancakes, perfect children's menu, crayons for little ones. Even baby crew showered with adoration!

Can get busy but warm vibes welcome solo diners too. Seniors praise delicious senior omelets, fresh breakfast sandwiches. Stuffed french toast satisfies sweet tooths.

Gluten-free, sugar-free syrup options for health-conscious. Signatures include biscuits and gravy, fried potatoes, sliced tomatoes. Tempting cheesecake dessert.

With ample parking, wheelchair accessibility, Michigan's Plus makes it easy for all to enjoy hearty homemade fare in lively, family-friendly atmosphere.

Most rave about outstanding diner classics at this local favorite among places to eat and restaurants in Plattsburgh, NY. As a regular says, “You can't go wrong here!”

MICHIGANS PLUS

Address: 313 Cornelia St, Plattsburgh, NY 12901, United States

Hours: 7 AM – 3 PM

Phone: +1 518-561-0537

14. McSweeney’s Red Hots & Restaurant

On US-9, McSweeney's Red Hots & Restaurant is a beloved local spot among places to eat in Plattsburgh NY. Known for serving the best Michigans in North Country.

A relaxed American restaurant hitting the spot for quick, casual fare. Menu stars tasty red hots hot dogs, though some find not very big. Burgers praised for being cooked right, if not exceptional. Unique Buffalo chicken wrap provides flavor change.

For sides, regular fries get thumbs up but chili fries underwhelm. Thick milkshakes made with hard ice cream satisfy basic cravings.

While prices rose, many still deem it a decent meal for quick highway stop. Highlights are delicious pies – staff freshly bakes whole chocolate pies.

Other wins – Michigan hot dogs, poutine showcasing specialties. Clean, spacious dining room provides welcoming family setting. Easy parking out front.

Friendly servers like Jane provide excellent, cheerful service. But recent visits marred by undercooked fries, overcooked bacon, lackluster burgers.

Despite inconsistencies, McSweeney's still ranks among best places to eat in Plattsburgh NY for authentic savory diner fare, famed Michigans in laidback roadside setting. As one local says, “Try their Michigans and poutine.”

MCSWEENEY’S RED HOTS & RESTAURANT

Address: 7067 US-9, Plattsburgh, NY 12901, United States

Hours: 11 AM – 4 PM

Phone: +1 518-562-9309

15. Olive Ridley's Restaurant

On Court St downtown, Olive Ridley's is a hopping bar and restaurant – a popular place to eat in Plattsburgh, NY. Known for fun atmosphere, live music, happy hour deals.

Attracts crowds with energetic vibe. Child-friendly options amid sometimes rowdy college scene. Building's quiet atmosphere contrasts later night revelry.

Don't expect high-end cuisine. Olive Ridley's is about classic bar bites done right. Highlights – meat pies, clam chowder, bangers and mash, tacos. But some underwhelm like fish and chips, coconut shrimp.

Still, decent beer, good drinks satisfy most. Few resist tantalizing kitchen aromas.

Mixed service reviews – can be attentive, sweet servers but also inattentive at times. Confident bartenders earn praise for drink knowledge.

Not a culinary star, but Olive Ridley's shines as lively downtown hangout for its social scene, affordable pub grub. As one local says, “Great spot for downtown Plattsburgh feel” among places to eat.

Expect an animated evening with loud music, colorful language, occasional rowdy incident. Part of the raucous, fun vibe at this beloved watering hole.

Olive Ridley's is a popular bar and eatery for the nightlife scene among places to eat in Plattsburgh NY.

OLIVE RIDLEY'S RESTAURANT

Address: 37 Court St, Plattsburgh, NY 12901, United States

Hours: 3 PM – 11 PM

Phone: +1 518-324-2200

Menu: oliveridleys.com

16. Aleka's

On Margaret St sits Aleka's – a cozy, down-to-earth eatery bringing the vibrant flavors of Greek, Mediterranean, Italian and Middle Eastern cuisine to Plattsburgh. This local gem offers a small but authentic menu of rich dishes in a relaxed setting.

Step inside (or dine outdoors on the patio) and you're transported to the Mediterranean with standouts like lamb gyros, dolmas, Greek salads and more. Vegetarians delight in offerings like falafel and falafel sandwiches. Don't miss the heavenly grape leaves when available.

Regulars rave about the flavorful, generous portions that provide delicious value. From juicy gyro meat to fresh feta blocks, the simple ingredients shine. Even classic fettuccine alfredo gets an upgrade with tender chicken and shrimp.

To start, the fries topped with feta never disappoint. While the sampler platter leaves some wanting more pita or falafel, the pickled veggies provide a bright contrast.

The warm service from the friendly staff further elevates the experience, though the limited drink menu is noteworthy only for Greek wines and brews. Occasional misses like burnt gyro meat can briefly disappoint.

Still, most cannot resist the authentic, robust flavors that make Aleka's a local standout among places to eat in Plattsburgh NY. As one fan proclaims, it offers a “travel to Greece” without leaving town.

So for a casual, comforting taste of the Mediterranean easily rivaling Montreal's GreekScene, grab a sunny table at Aleka's. With its high-quality fare at fair prices, it's anunmissable dining gem in downtown Plattsburgh.

ALEKA'S

Address: 103 Margaret St, Plattsburgh, NY 12901, United States

Hours: 4 PM – 9 PM

Phone: +1 518-310-3200

Whether you're looking for a quick bite or an upscale dining experience, Plattsburgh has a variety of restaurant options serving delicious cuisines. After staying at cheap hotels in Plattsburgh NY, you can stroll around the city and discover unique local eateries.

17. Conclusion about places to eat in Plattsburgh NY

Plattsburgh, NY, is a food lover's paradise, with an impressive selection of restaurants that offer something for everyone. From the cozy ambiance of Quiche et Crepe to the lively atmosphere of Texas Roadhouse, these top places to eat in Plattsburgh NY deliver exceptional dining experiences.

Whether you're craving classic American comfort food, authentic ethnic cuisines, or innovative craft cocktails, you'll find it all among these highly recommended Plattsburgh restaurants. So, the next time you're looking for a memorable meal in Plattsburgh, be sure to visit one of these outstanding places to eat and discover why the city's culinary scene is truly something special.